Join the RPGBOT crew as they wrap up their Pulp Cthulhu experiment — answering listener questions, unpacking mechanics, debating wizard builds, and confirming once and for all that Pulp Cthulhu is less “existential dread” and more “Indiana Jones punches Nazis with a jetpack.”
Show Notes
The finale Q&A session closes out the RPGBOT Quickstart series on Pulp Cthulhu with a reflective, mechanics-focused discussion on how the system actually played at the table. Framed as a conversation between players and Keeper, the episode explores whether the rules felt intuitive, what stood out, and how pulp action changes the traditional Call of Cthulhu experience.
The discussion opens with character advancement — a system largely inherited from Classic Call of Cthulhu. Skills that succeed during play are marked, and during the development phase players roll to see if they improve — ironically increasing faster in weaker skills than stronger ones. This reinforces the system’s organic growth model and is supplemented in Pulp by rewards like bonus Luck for completing story arcs.
From there, the hosts explore how survivability mechanics shift the tone. Luck emerges as a defining feature of pulp play, enabling cinematic survival and bold risk-taking. The group reflects on moments where characters survived explosive stunts specifically because Luck allowed them to — a core distinction from the deadlier classic ruleset.
Combat mechanics and optimization debates dominate the mid-episode. The team examines whether investing in unarmed combat can ever compete with firearms, concluding that while high damage bonuses and melee weapons help, impaling weapons and guns remain significantly deadlier due to extreme success multipliers.
This highlights the game’s grounded lethality — fists can work, but physics (and dice math) favor bullets.
The Q&A also ventures into magic, psychic powers, and build decisions. Spellcasting is contextualized as powerful but dangerous, balanced by sanity costs and narrative risk. Psychic abilities, meanwhile, shine in investigation-driven play, especially those focused on information gathering rather than raw damage.
Beyond mechanics, the episode emphasizes tone. Pulp Cthulhu thrives on cinematic improvisation and narrative escalation — encouraging Keepers to “yes-and” player creativity while maintaining credible stakes. The system sits between absurd heroics and genuine peril, echoing adventure films where quips and danger coexist. Balancing that tone is presented as the central challenge for running the game effectively.
The session concludes with reflections comparing Classic and Pulp styles. Players note that pulp’s higher success rates and survivability foster emotional investment and character attachment, contrasting with the grim inevitability of failure common in classic play.
Ultimately, the Q&A serves as both debrief and endorsement — showcasing Pulp Cthulhu as a system that rewards boldness, supports cinematic storytelling, and invites players to lean into chaotic adventure while still respecting cosmic horror roots.
Support RPGBOT by Visiting our Affiliate Partners
- Amazon – All of your regular online shopping, plus support RPGBOT.
- Cantrip Candles – The original TTRPG candle.
- DMsGuild and DriveThruRPG – The leading source of PDF source books
- dScryb – Proprietors of finely-crafted “boxed text.” Use coupon code “RPGBOT” at checkout for 10% off your first subscription payment or “RPGBOT5” for $5 off your first subscription payment.
- Easy Roller Dice – Dice, dice trays, dice jails, and other tabletop gaming accessories. Use coupon code “RPGBOT” at checkout for 15% off your purchase
- Ezoic – RPGBOT’s long-time banner ad provider. If you have a cool website, Ezoic is really great.
- Heroforge – The premiere provider of custom miniatures.
- Humble Bundle – Buy bundles of games and game products at a massive discount and support both RPGBOT and charity.
Support the Pod
If you enjoy the show, please rate and review us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast app. It’s a quick, free way to support the podcast, and helps us reach new listeners.
If you love the show, consider joining us on Patreon, where backers at the $5 and above tiers get ad free access to RPGBOT.net and the RPGBOT.Podcast, direct access to the RPGBOT.Team on the RPGBOT.Discord, and can join us every week for live-streamed recordings.
Support us on Amazon.com when you purchase products recommended in the show at the following link: https://amzn.to/3NwElxQ
How to Find Us:
In-depth articles, guides, handbooks, reviews, news on Tabletop Role Playing at RPGBOT.net
Tyler Kamstra
Ash Ely
- Professional Game Master on StartPlaying.Games
- Join Ash’s West Marches-style PF2 Game
- Bluesky: GravenAshes
- YouTube: @ashravenmedia
Randall James
- AmateurJack.com
- Bluesky: @JackAmateur
- Read Melancon: A Grimoire Tale
